Lines and Colors art blog

James Abbott McNeill Whistler

James Abbott McNeill Whistler - Symphony in White, No 2: The Little White Girl, Nocturne: Blue and Silver - Chelsea
For reasons that are beyond me, the image most popularly associated with Whistler is not, as it is with most artists, one of his artistic pinnacles; but, at least in my opinion, one of his least successful and least interesting works, Arrangement in Grey and Black: The Artist’s Mother, known commonly at “Whistler’s Mother”.

How this particular painting became an icon of American art is a mystery I find too uninteresting to pursue. Whistler’s overall body of work, however, his muted tonalist masterpieces, evocative portraits and stunningly beautiful etchings, make him one of the most under-appreciated “famous” artists that I can bring to mind.

While many of his Victorian contemporaries spoke boldly in voices of Academic clarity or Pre-Raphaelite finesse, and the more adventurous shouted with Impressionistic abandon, Whistler… whispered.

Influenced both by the free brushwork of Impressionism and the solid foundation of Academic training (like many of the so-called “American Impressionists”), Whistler, even more than the others, took great inspiration from the spare, open and visually poetic compositions of Japanese prints, which were a popular import into England and Europe at the time.

Though he is considered an American painter, Whistler, like Sargent, spent the better part of his life in Europe (England, actually) and was European in his sensibilities.

The son of an engineer, Whistler went to the West Point Military Academy, where he did poorly but came away with enough acumen from drawing class to be employed mapping the entire U.S. coast for the Military, a job he hated almost as much as school, though the etching skills he acquired would serve him well later.

Whistler despised the way Americans held art and artists in low esteem in comparison to Europeans (a situation that continues to this day, as far as I can tell); and on leaving to seek artistic training in Europe, never returned to the U.S. He subsequently spent much effort, in the course of his continual re-invention of his persona, denying his birthplace in Lowell, Massachusetts — alternately claiming to be a disenfranchised Southern aristocrat or born in St. Petersburg, Russia.

Whistler’s antics, his often arrogant and abrasive personality, dandified appearance and relentless self-promotion can be as misleading as his iconic portrait of his mother in discerning the real painter. For that, seek out his other portraits, like Purple and Rose: The Large Leizen of the Six Marks (one of my favorites in the Philadelphia Museum of Art) or Symphony in White, No 2: The Little White Girl (image above, top); or his beautiful, poetic “nocturnes”, soft harmonies of mist and atmosphere, like Nocturne: Blue and Silver – Chelsea (above, bottom).

In these works, and his masterful etchings (Whistler is my second favorite etcher next to Rembrandt), you can see Whistler as the major figure in art that his rather drab portrait of his mother and overly colorful personal behavior might otherwise obscure.

Fortunately, there are many resources on Whistler, numerous books, including a very nice and inexpensive Dover book of his etchings, and lots of web resources, some of which I’ve gathered for you below.

If you live in or near New York, now is a good time to re-discover Whistler, as the Frick Collection is presenting a beautiful little show culled from their own impressive holdings: Portraits, Pastels, Prints: Whistler in The Frick Collection from now until August 23, 2009.

If you’re not familiar with the “real” Whistler, don’t let him hide behind his mother’s skirts, seek out his quiet brilliance in the paintings and etchings where he composes his visual “symphonies”.


4 responses to “James Abbott McNeill Whistler”

  1. Another great post, Charley. (You know at some point this stopped being a blog and became a full-fledged web resource that remains deisguised as a blog.)

    Re: “Whistler’s Mother.” In spite of Whistler’s determination to keep the title as well as the presentation of the image anything but sentimental, early 20th century (especially Depression era viewers) nonetheless responded in a thorouighly sentimental manner and the image went iconic the way videos go viral today. Very like Grant Wood’s “American Gothic” another unsuccessful attempt at being UN-sentimental…

    1. Thanks, Dan. That would account for it.

  2. I did a project on Whistler a while back and concluded that he was a greatly under-rated artist. This is the resources site I created at the time – although I notice that I still have to update it for all the links I found!

    James McNeill Whistler – Resources for Art Lovers

  3. taimoor Avatar

    hello sir
    i am interested in ur blog
    but i cant answer some of my questions that come to me such as the quality of the blog if i am interested in learning about art is it suggetable to read blogs they appear so informal
    do you write about painting techniques
    do you post references from well known books when appreciating old or contemporary masters
    how can i find other blogs about paintings
    do you know how can i find free art magazines or books from internet